Table 6. Performance measures for diameter and cross-section area by model type and relative height class.

Target Relative height classa Mixed-effects Fixed-effects
BIAS MAB RMSE FI BIAS MAB RMSE FI
Diameter 0.025 0.0314 (84.2)b 0.3685 (69.8) 0.4889 (68.7) 0.9968 (3.1) 0.1991 1.2208 1.5600 0.9670
0.05 0.2392 (−40.6) 0.4955 (33.9) 0.6730 (31.4) 0.9907 (1.1) 0.1701 0.7491 0.9808 0.9803
0.1 −0.3022 (3.8) 0.4773 (12.8) 0.5888 (11.8) 0.9933 (0.2) −0.3140 0.5471 0.6679 0.9914
0.2 0.1344 (−16.5) 0.4415 (33.7) 0.5771 (34.0) 0.9929 (0.9) 0.1154 0.6664 0.8750 0.9838
0.3 0.1085 (−103.9) 0.4525 (36.7) 0.5844 (37.8) 0.9920 (1.3) 0.0532 0.7145 0.9389 0.9792
0.4 0.0299 (9.7) 0.5005 (38.5) 0.6376 (38.9) 0.9858 (2.5) 0.0331 0.8132 1.0442 0.9619
0.5 −0.1095 (16.5) 0.5183 (41.4) 0.6692 (39.3) 0.9818 (3.3) −0.1312 0.8847 1.1033 0.9504
0.6 −0.1581 (6.5) 0.5531 (43.2) 0.7047 (41.8) 0.9721 (5.9) −0.1691 0.9746 1.2108 0.9177
0.7 0.0250 (49.5) 0.4433 (53.4) 0.5758 (52.6) 0.9760 (9.3) 0.0495 0.9512 1.2160 0.8929
0.8 0.1237 (−30.3) 0.4579 (52.8) 0.5887 (52.9) 0.9653 (14.4) 0.0949 0.9699 1.2486 0.8441
0.9 −0.0125 (63.6) 0.5481 (41.2) 0.7038 (40.5) 0.9245 (17.5) −0.0343 0.9326 1.1835 0.7865
1.0 −0.0605 (37.8) 0.5554 (17.5) 0.7295 (14.9) 0.7259 (16.9) −0.0973 0.6731 0.8577 0.6211
Cross-section area 0.025 −0.0692 (101.5) 16.5335 (70.1) 22.9821 (68.7) 0.9968 (3.1) 4.5644 55.2134 73.5414 0.9671
0.05 11.7285 (−37.5) 22.9883 (33.1) 33.5608 (30.5) 0.9897 (1.1) 8.5320 34.3818 48.2985 0.9786
0.1 −11.3460 (2.8) 17.3223 (8.2) 22.9259 (2.0) 0.9933 (0.0) −11.6759 18.8681 23.4045 0.9930
0.2 6.9286 (9.0) 17.4438 (34.6) 25.4042 (33.8) 0.9903 (1.3) 7.6108 26.6709 38.3540 0.9778
0.3 4.0948 (−4.4) 14.6331 (39.1) 20.7979 (40.8) 0.9909 (1.7) 3.9233 24.0446 35.1342 0.9739
0.4 0.8419 (61.4) 15.6621 (39.4) 21.6248 (40.4) 0.9833 (3.2) 2.1827 25.8495 36.2989 0.9529
0.5 −2.5471 (−23.3) 13.5354 (42.3) 19.5459 (39.3) 0.9773 (4.1) −2.0654 23.4667 32.1851 0.9384
0.6 −3.4236 (−26.8) 12.7644 (42.8) 17.9326 (40.6) 0.9646 (7.2) −2.7005 22.3235 30.2043 0.8996
0.7 1.1112 (55.2) 8.4518 (53.8) 12.0786 (52.8) 0.9724 (11.0) 2.4824 18.2897 25.6040 0.8762
0.8 2.6013 (19.4) 6.6099 (53.7) 9.6522 (53.9) 0.9595 (18.5) 3.2287 14.2757 20.9404 0.8095
0.9 1.0071 (35.9) 5.1809 (42.5) 7.8109 (43.6) 0.9153 (24.8) 1.5718 9.0116 13.8593 0.7334
1.0 −0.4965 (−61.9) 2.3512 (18.1) 4.0704 (11.1) 0.7010 (12.8) −0.3066 2.8704 4.5803 0.6214
Diameter 0.025 0.1117 (84.2)b 1.3122 (69.8) 1.7413 (68.7) 0.7089 4.3476 5.5558
0.05 0.8471 (−40.6) 1.7546 (33.8) 2.3828 (31.4) 0.6024 2.6523 3.4730
0.1 −1.3525 (3.8) 2.1363 (12.8) 2.6353 (11.8) −1.4052 2.4485 2.9890
0.2 0.5779 (−16.5) 1.8992 (33.7) 2.4822 (34.0) 0.4962 2.8663 3.7637
0.3 0.5541 (−104.0) 2.3112 (36.7) 2.9852 (37.8) 0.2716 3.6497 4.7960
0.4 0.1589 (9.5) 2.6576 (38.5) 3.3853 (38.9) 0.1756 4.3178 5.5441
0.5 −0.6962 (16.5) 3.2948 (41.4) 4.2539 (39.3) −0.8340 5.6235 7.0133
0.6 −1.1535 (6.5) 4.0367 (43.2) 5.1432 (41.8) −1.2340 7.1129 8.8364
0.7 0.2185 (49.4) 3.8674 (53.4) 5.0233 (52.6) 0.4321 8.2985 10.6086
0.8 1.4232 (−30.3) 5.2690 (52.8) 6.7744 (52.9) 1.0920 11.1609 14.3682
0.9 −0.2262 (63.5) 9.9079 (41.2) 12.7233 (40.5) −0.6198 16.8580 21.3947
1.0 −2.6325 (37.9) 24.1764 (17.5) 31.7524 (14.9) −4.2369 29.2954 37.3333
Cross-section area 0.025 −0.0102 (101.5) 2.4418 (70.1) 3.3942 (68.7) 0.6741 8.1544 10.8612
0.05 1.7643 (−37.5) 3.4581 (33.1) 5.0486 (30.5) 1.2835 5.1721 7.2656
0.1 −2.6213 (2.8) 4.0020 (8.2) 5.2967 (2.0) −2.6975 4.3592 5.4073
0.2 1.5011 (9.0) 3.7791 (34.6) 5.5037 (33.8) 1.6488 5.7782 8.3093
0.3 1.2248 (−4.4) 4.3767 (39.1) 6.2206 (40.8) 1.1735 7.1917 10.5086
0.4 0.2796 (61.4) 5.2024 (39.4) 7.1830 (40.4) 0.7250 8.5863 12.0572
0.5 −1.1922 (−23.3) 6.3353 (42.3) 9.1486 (39.3) −0.9667 10.9837 15.0644
0.6 −2.1205 (−26.8) 7.9058 (42.8) 11.1068 (40.6) −1.6726 13.8264 18.7075
0.7 0.9744 (55.2) 7.4118 (53.8) 10.5923 (52.8) 2.1770 16.0391 22.4534
0.8 3.8734 (19.4) 9.8421 (53.7) 14.3722 (53.9) 4.8076 21.2566 31.1804
0.9 3.4506 (35.9) 17.7510 (42.5) 26.7621 (43.6) 5.3854 30.8759 47.4855
1.0 −8.7566 (−62.0) 41.4635 (18.1) 71.7815 (11.1) −5.4069 50.6200 80.7747
Relative height classes: 0.025 = (0, 0.025], 0.05 = (0.025, 0.05], 0.1 = (0.05, 0.1], 0.2 = (0.1, 0.2], …, 0.9 = (0.8, 0.9], 1.0 = (0.9, 1.0]
The number in the parenthesis represents the percentage by which the mixed-effects model improves the fixed-effects one.