Table 2. Thinning intensity of first and second thinning by experimental site in Korean white pine plantation.

Thinning experimental site Plot First thinning Second thinning Thinning intensity class (1st → 2nd)
No. of trees before thinning (trees/ha) Thinning intensity (%) No. of trees after thinning (trees/ha) Thinning quotient No. of trees before thinning (trees/ha) Thinning intensity (%) No. of trees after thinning (trees/ha) Thinning quotient
Stem number basis Basal area basis Stem number basis Basal area basis
Site 1 A 2944 68 50 946 0.86 920 17 8 762 0.70 Heavy → Light
B 2972 57 38 1285 0.82 1259 45 30 696 0.82 Moderate → Moderate
C 2901 43 21 1642 0.70 1423 67 50 465 0.87 Light → Heavy
D 2831 0 0 2831 0 1897 0 0 1897 0 Unthinned → Unthinned
Site 2 A 2786 56 38 1227 0.83 1201 28 14 869 0.80 Heavy → Light
B 2745 43 26 1569 0.78 1333 41 30 784 0.84 Moderate → Moderate
C 3240 40 28 1928 0.83 1848 64 50 669 0.87 Light → Heavy
D 3087 0 0 3087 0 1752 0 0 1752 0 Unthinned → Unthinned
Site 3 A 1595 61 48 618 0.88 618 0 0 618 0 Heavy → Unthinned
B 1879 43 23 1063 0.73 1026 11 9 915 0.82 Moderate → Light
C 1683 18 8 1471 0.66 1185 29 23 836 0.73 Light → Moderate
D 1787 0 0 1787 0 1170 34 29 768 0.76 Unthinned → Heavy