Table 4. Analysis of the 2nd and 3rd round Delphi survey– Scope of local forestry.

Classification 2nda 3rdb
Frequencyc Percentaged Frequencyc Percentaged
지역임업의 공간적 범위 (spatial range of local forestry)
지역사회-행정구역에 국한되지 않고 경제 공동체가 형성될 수 있는 지역사회 (local community-a community where an economic community can be formed without being limited to administrative districts) 12 57.1 13 68.4
기초지방자치단체-시·군 단위 (fundamental local governments) 8 38.1 6 31.6
광역자치단체-도 단위 (metropolitan and provincial governments) 1 4.8 0 0
Total 21 100 19 100
지역임업에서 다루어야 하는 산림사업의 범위 (scope of forestry business that should be covered in local forestry)
산림경영기반 (base of forest management) 18 85.7 17 89.5
산림보호 (forest protection) 13 61.9 11 57.9
임목 생산 (timber production) 19 90.5 18 94.7
산림바이오매스 (forest biomass) 18 85.7 16 84.2
비목재 임산물 생산·가공·유통 (production·processing·distribution of forest byproduct) 17 81.0 15 78.9
산림휴양치유 (forest recreation and healing) 14 66.7 14 73.7
산림관광 (forest tourism) 20 95.2 19 100
산림교육 (forest education) 16 76.2 16 84.2
Total 21 100 19 100
지역임업 주체의 범위 (scope of local forestry subjects)
지역주민 (local residents) 20 95.2 18 94.7
산주 (forest owners) 19 90.5 17 89.5
산림조합 (forestry cooperatives federation) 14 66.7 10 52.6
산림관련 지역 공동체 (forest related local communities) 20 95.2 18 94.7
산림관련 교육기관 (forest related educational organizations) 7 33.3 6 31.6
지자체 (local governments) 19 90.5 18 94.7
임업경영주체 및 종사자 (forestry entities and workers) 산림사업법인 (forest enterprise corporation) 14 66.7 (M)72.6 12 63.2 (M)77.6
목재 분야 (timber) 16 76.2 16 84.2
비목재 임산물 분야 (forest byproduct) 16 76.2 15 78.9
산림복지서비스 분야 (forest welfare service) 15 71.4 16 84.2
Total 21 100 19 100
지역임업 주체가 추구해야 하는 가치 (values that local forestry subjects should pursue)
사적인 이익 (private interest) 1 0 0 0 0
2 3 14.3 0 0
3 5 23.8 5 26.3
4 5 23.8 9 47.4
5 4 19.0 3 15.8
공익적 가치 (public value) 6 2 9.5 1 5.3
7 1 4.8 1 5.3
Total 20 95.2 19 100
Missing values 1 4.8 0 0
n=21
n=19
Duplicate responses are allowed
Rounded to two decimal places